Skip to main content

While legislators are scrambling to regulate AI, Elon Musk is calling for a six-month moratorium. The cat is out of the bag. The public is torn between awe and apprehension. Will your job be safe or even exist in the future? And who will be the manager of tomorrow, if entry level jobs are occupied by AI chatbots?

Economists use the words “low-skill” and “high-skill” to distinguish between different types of workers, implying that those with “high-skills” were able to perform not only the tasks that low-skilled workers do but also other, more demanding tasks. The reality is far different, as anybody who has met a university professor knows.

Workers have different abilities, and the traditional classification reflects differences in years of schooling and an associated labor market premium. This premium includes higher monetary compensation, better conditions, fewer job-related hazards, etc. But why do more years of schooling lead to such improved working conditions?

One basic assumption would be that for an individual to spend the time and resources necessary to complete such a degree, he or she must demand a premium. Yet many students specialize in areas with relatively poor career prospects such as the humanities, social work or journalism. A second hypothesis is that workers who can complete a university degree show non-cognitive “skills” that are likely associated with success in other fields. While this may be true in many cases, the massive expansion of university-level education since the 1970s has substantially reduced its positive “signaling” effect, but the associated premium has continued to increase.

An important dimension in which college-educated workers distinguish themselves is the ability to communicate and persuade effectively, often in written form. This ability has been enormously profitable in an economy that has tilted ever more to professional services and human interactions and away from manufacturing. Lawyers, consultants, representatives, PR advisors, etc., have enjoyed very high returns on their ability to understand complex information, process it and communicate it effectively. Technological change, in the form of computers, has empowered these workers to perform their tasks without the help of an army of secretaries and clerks, further increasing their returns.

Things are about to change with the development of high-powered artificial intelligence (AI) models, such as ChatGPT or Bard. The ability to communicate effectively, at least in written form, is now accessible to many more workers. Just as computers eliminated the need for secretaries, these AI machines will remove the need for low-level professionals at service firms (legal clerks and paralegals, analysts, junior consultants, etc.).

Yet a fundamental difference exists. Workers who began as secretaries in the 1940s did not move up the corporate ladder, while these “lower-level” professionals are typically entry-level positions in highly pyramid-structured corporations. Today’s analysts can be tomorrow’s partners. If consultants no longer need these analysts, who will replace them when they retire?

What does history teach us? The closest example from the past is the spread of ATMs in the early 1990s. ATMs replaced the most basic task of bank employees (“tellers”), many of whom did climb the ladder to commercial and management positions. Perhaps surprisingly, the efficiency improvements in banking led to an expansion in their business, driving banks to recruit heavily for the following 20 years, until the financial crises of 2008. Bank workers thrived because they specialized in tasks that could not be replaced by machines.

Will ChatGPT be different? Only time will tell. For now, the reader can ponder whether this text was written by an AI-powered chatbot or a formerly highly skilled worker.

Picture: 10  February , photomontage, face with computer boards and writing ChatGPT © IMAGO / Christian Ohde

More News

DeepSeek on a smartphone DeepSeek sanctioned for security concern...

Putin: Artificial Intelligence Journey international conference The BRICS+ AI Alliance: Towards A Multip...

tower against sunset Neurosymbolic AI: A Solution for Air Saf...

Latest

1750 map of Palestine published by Homannsche Erben Israeli Wartime Landgrabs: Who will be h...

Indians protest outside the Pakistan embassy Great Britain’s Not-So-Great Colonial Le...

Dog waiting for adoption Trump Administration Stops Taxpayer Fund...

Related Articles

Elephants closeup shot Do Elephants Hold the Key to Understandi...

Mobile phone with logo of fundraising organization ActBlue Charities Inc. Inside ActBlue: The Scandal Eroding the ...

Euclid space telescope Dark Energy and Dark Matter – ESA’...

Innovation

VBC Austria The Vienna BioCenter – A Leading Hub for...

US China Quantum Computing US and China Set Sights on Becoming Glob...

PEGASUS PEGASUS –The First Nanosatellite Exclusi...

Pioneers

The Adams Presidential Dynasty and Visio...

Golden Statue of Johann Strauss II Johann Strauss II: The 200th Anniversary...

Hedy Lamarr Hedy Lamarr – Hollywood Star and the ‘Mo...

Cartoon

Cartoon Stariff WarsSTARiff WARS
President Trump's trade war targets China with massive tariffs to 'boost' a flagging economy. By Mark Winter (Chicane), 4 June 2025.

Social Media

Language Articles

Israeli Wartime Landgrabs: Who will be held accountable?

Китай Бросает Вызов США в Организации Американских Государств

Acuerdo UE-Mercosur: ¿Sueño hecho realidad o pesadilla neoliberal?

密苏里州起诉中国:法庭对决还是徒劳僵局?

Dunkle Energie und Dunkle Materie – ESAs Versuch, das Universum zu erklären

يوهان شتراوس الثاني: الذكرى المئوية الثانية لنجم موسيقى الفالس في فيينا

La Suède a encore besoin de livres

WordPress Cookie Notice by Real Cookie Banner